Superintendent Presents Boundary Review Recommendations
August 22nd, 2019
Howard County Public School System Superintendent Dr. Michael J. Martirano presented his recommendations to balance school capacity utilization, provide relief to schools most impacted by crowding, and address inequities in the distribution of students affected by poverty, during the Howard County Board of Education meeting on Tuesday, August 20, 2019.
The Board initiated by unanimous vote on January 24, 2019, a systemwide boundary review process, prompted by significant imbalances in school capacity utilization. Currently, 32 schools (43%) are outside of the target capacity utilization defined in HCPSS Policy 6010, meaning that enrollment at these schools is either below 90% or over 110% of their capacity, while the distribution of students participating in the Free and Reduced-price Meals program (FARMs) ranges from below 5% at some schools to up to 68% at others.
“This recommendation marks a turning point in how we look at attendance area adjustments. While previous boundary review processes focused more narrowly on capacity utilization, my proposal is in alignment with our Strategic Call to Action, leading with equity as our driver to provide all students with full access and opportunity to receive the best educational services and supports,” Martirano said.
The Superintendent’s proposal, which relates to school boundaries for the 2020–2021 school year (SY 20–21), moves beyond the recommendations presented in the 2019 Feasibility Study, and takes into account the priorities expressed by his Attendance Area Committee (AAC), the 800 participants in four community input sessions, and 2,176 surveys and 276 alternative scenarios submitted by community members and other stakeholders.
Also considered during planning were transportation times and costs, the effective use of existing school resources, and other Policy 6010 standards. These priorities also included keeping school boundaries contiguous while maintaining neighborhood schools and walkable distances for as many students as possible.
The Superintendent’s proposal would provide for reassignment of approximately 7,396 students, including 3,194 elementary, 1,351 middle, and 2,851 high school students. Through the proposal, 53 schools are projected to be within the 90–110% target capacity utilization defined in policy, compared with 42 without boundary adjustments, and many of the most highly-impacted schools would see significant relief.
The proposal also advances socio-economic equity by addressing the proportion among schools of students receiving FARM program services. Through the Superintendent’s proposal, all elementary schools would have a FARM rate at or below 54%, and the number of elementary schools above 50% would be reduced by half, from 12 to 6. The 10 elementary schools with highest FARM rates would be reduced by a combined 82%, and 21 schools would move closer to the county average.
FARM levels for all middle schools would be at or below 45% through Martirano’s proposal, which reduces levels for the five middle schools with highest rates by a combined 38%, while 11 schools would move closer to the county average.
For high schools, FARM rates would be at or below 42% for all schools, and the four with highest rates currently would be reduced by a combined 18%. Nine high schools would move closer to the county average.
Martirano’s proposal also plans ahead for new High School #13, which is scheduled to open fall 2023, by minimizing the impact for high schools and families that are most likely to be affected by boundary adjustments for the new school.
In delivering his recommendation, the Superintendent emphasized the system’s great strength and the excellence of every Howard County public school. “Regardless of the outcome of this process, every child in our county will continue to have access to an excellent education. We are not a system of individual schools; we are a cohesive school system with consistent curriculum, excellent teachers, small class sizes, and comparable learning and enrichment opportunities at every school,” Martirano said.
More information, including the Superintendent’s presentation and full report given to the Board of Education and a one-page document that details the proposal are available on the HCPSS website.
The Board will hold three public hearings and seven work sessions, and is scheduled to make a final decision on any boundary line adjustments with action on Thursday, November 21. A full schedule and complete information about the boundary review process is provided online.